Home » Car Seat Brands » Best Graco Car Seats Reviews & Comparison

Best Graco Car Seats Reviews & Comparison

Joanne Stene
Last Updated on
by Joanne Stene

Choosing the right car seat for your child can be one of the most intimidating things you experience as a parent. That’s because there are so many different variables to consider, and some car seats are much better than others.

You have enough to worry about as a parent! That’s why in this comprehensive guide you’re going to learn all about the Graco line of children car seats. Graco is among the top leading brands of car seats, and we’re about to take a deeper look into their most popular and highly rated models.

Which Graco car seat is right for you, your child, your lifestyle, and your entire family? Let’s investigate more so you can choose the perfect match without any stress, overwhelm, or second-guessing.

Graco Convertible Car Seats Comparison

1. Graco Extend2Fit

The Graco Extend2Fit is a lovely convertible car seat. This car seat offers a rear-facing position and a forward-facing position. The pads are machine washable, the design of the car seat looks stylish, and the leg room of this model is rated 4.8-stars on Amazon.

Another great feature of this car seat is that the harness easily extends along with the headrest. This way, you can easily adjust the car seat for optimal comfort and safety.


  • Rear-facing position: 4 to 50 pounds
  • Forward-facing position: 22 to 65 pounds
  • Car seat weight: 23.2 pounds

The Graco Extend2Fit is an impressive car seat that’s designed to ensure the greatest comfort for your child. This car seat is an excellent choice for small babies and preemies who are as small as 4 pounds.

Another feature of this car seat is that the rear-facing weight limit is 50 pounds. The 50-pound weight limit for the rear-facing position that this model offers is the highest in this entire list. If you like the idea of having your child ride in the rear-facing position, then this is a standout feature that other car seats don’t usually match.

This model also contains all the safety features you would expect. Features include a hassle-free LATCH installation system, a steel frame, and harness storage that keeps the buckle out of the way. All in all, this car seat offers an excellent combination of safety and economical features and is well rounded.

The Graco Extend2Fit is also very well reviewed and has an average rating of 4.6-stars after 3,304 customers have left their reviews. 77% of reviewers have rated this car seat as a 5-star car seat, so you can be confident that this car seat is indeed very well received.

  • Boasts an impressive rear-facing weight limit of 50 pounds
  • Accommodates children up to 49 inches tall
  • Easily adjust the headrest and harness height in one movement
  • A headrest that offers 10 different positions
  • Affordable with lots of positive reviews
  • Max weight limit of only 65 pounds
  • Some users complain that the straps are difficult to tighten

2. Graco 4Ever 4-in-1

The Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat is designed to accommodate your child’s growth. The impressive flexibility options of this car seat are arguably unmatched. That’s because this car seat can accommodate babies as small as 4 pounds, and large children who are up to 120 pounds.

For that reason, this car seat might be your best bet if you’re seeking a reliable, long-lasting choice.


  • Rear-facing position: 4 to 40 pounds
  • Forward-facing position: 22 to 65 pounds
  • Booster seat in high back mode: 30 to 100 pounds
  • Booster seat in backless mode: 40 to 120 pounds
  • Weight: 22.8 pounds

This car seat has many rave reviews from parents who have unfortunately been in car accidents with their child seated inside. The safety of your child is your number one responsibility as a parent, and therefore, this model is worth a very close look.

The four different positions that this convertible car seat offers helps support your child as they grow, which is a big deal. You want to ensure that your child is safe and comfortable in their travels, and this model has all the safety features you would expect from a top brand.

The Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat is also very well reviewed , with a 4.7-star rating after 1,829 customer reviews. It’s also important to note that an overwhelming 80% of reviewers rate this car seat as a 5-star car seat.

  • Very versatile boasting 4 different convertible modes
  • Impressive maximum weight limit of 120 pounds
  • Accommodates small babies as small as 4 pounds
  • Accommodates children as tall as 57 inches
  • Several users passionately state that this car seat handles crashes well
  • One of the more expensive seats on this list
  • Several users have complained that the headrest unit makes a rattling sound
  • This seat is designed to stay in your car and is not compatible with strollers

3. Graco Contender 65

If you’re looking for a simple car seat for your baby, while not sacrificing style or safety, then the Graco Contender 65 is worth learning more about.

The Graco Contender 65 is designed for your small baby and is engineered with safety and economy in mind. This seat also includes both rear-facing and forward-facing positions.

The Graco Contender makes for the perfect solution for your seat needs without any of the fuss or extra bells and whistles.


  • Rear-facing position: 5 to 40 pounds
  • Forward-facing position: 20 to 65 pounds
  • Weight: 15.2 pounds

The Graco Contender 65 is the perfect car seat if you want a stylish and safe seat that won’t break the bank. An excellent feature that this seat offers is that it can accommodate your small infant in a rear-facing position. Also, as your child grows the car seat transitions to a forward-facing position.

One thing that you’ll love about the Graco Contender 65 is that it’s been tested with a side impact crash test and meets or exceeds US safety standards. This car seat also boasts a headrest with 8 different positions, so your child is always snug, secure, and comfortable in their seat.

  • Accommodate babies as small as 5 pounds
  • The car seat itself is very light at only 15.2 pounds
  • Harness system that automatically adjusts
  • Very affordable
  • Rigorously crash tested to meet US standards
  • Max weight limit of only 65 pounds
  • Users have said that the seat is difficult to remove from the vehicle due to the inconvenient location of the harness strap release button

Graco Infant Car Seat

1. Graco SnugRide 35

If you want a car seat that’s very easy to install, that has a very low profile, and that’s highly rated then the Graco SnugRide 35 might be worth a look.

Another reason why this car seat is worth mentioning is that it’s very light. The car seat also easily secures in your vehicle either with a seat belt or the included LATCH system that’s highly praised.

Specifications :

  • Rear-facing position: 4 to 35 pounds
  • Weight with base: 14.17 pounds
  • Weight without base: 7.5 pounds

One of the most stressful things when choosing the perfect car seat is figuring out if the car seat can help to keep your child safe during a crash. There have been a few Amazon reviewers of this car seat who say how this model handles crashes well, which is a huge area of consideration.

This car seat boasts all the features that you would expect from a top car seat brand. Features include a stylish look, a simple installation process, and the ability to connect to a Graco Click Connect stroller. You can find comfort that this model has been crash-tested and meets NHTSA regulations. (If you’re unfamiliar, NHTSA stands for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.)

The Graco SnugRide 35 is very well reviewed , with an average of 4.4-stars after 736 customers reviews. 67% of users rated this car seat as 5-stars, and 16% rated the car seat with 4-stars. It’s also important to note that Amazon users rated this model’s ease of installation as 4.8-stars and the safety features and durability both as 4.7-stars.

  • Super low profile and super light at only 7.5 pounds without base
  • Easily attaches to any Graco Click Connect stroller
  • No assembly required
  • Very affordable
  • Many excellent reviews including users who have experienced car crashes and who swear by this car seat and the safety that it provides
  • This seat is only rear-facing and has no forward-facing option
  • Only accommodates infants from 4 to 35 pounds.

Graco Booster Car Seats

1. Graco Affix Youth

The Graco Affix Youth Booster Seat is the perfect car seat for your growing child of between 30 and 100 pounds.

The car seat itself is very vibrant and stylish and contains all the pockets and storage that the modern-day child would love to have. This seat is one of the most well reviewed on this entire list, so it’s worthy of looking into.


  • Highback mode: 30 to 100 pounds
  • Backless mode: 40 to 100 pounds
  • Weight: 9.8 pounds

Are you frustrated because the car seats that you’ve been looking at weigh a ton?

If that’s the case, then the Graco Affix Youth Booster Seat might be the perfect car seat for you. This car seat is crash tested, comes with enhanced safety features such as energy absorbing foam, and is also very simple to install.

The car seat has two different modes. The first mode is the Highback mode. The Highback mode is perfect for children of 30 to 100 pounds. When your child eventually outgrows the Highback mode, this car seat easily transitions to a Backless mode. You can get more bang for your buck with this car seat, and your child won’t have to suffer the annoyance of switching car seats every year.

The reviews for the Graco Affix Youth Booster Seat are stellar. It has earned 3,380 reviews, making this one of the most popular car seats on this list. The users of this car seat have left a 4.6-star rating on average, and 74% of reviewers said that this seat deserves a 5-star rating. An additional 16% of reviewers said that the car seat is worthy of a 4-star rating, so the ratings are excellent.

Several of the users have left fantastic reviews saying that this car seat has kept their children safe during car crashes! Remember that the number one priority when finding a car seat is safety, so reviews such as this are critical and indicative of a quality car seat.

  • Very affordable
  • Accommodate children up to 57 inches tall in Backless mode
  • Plenty of storage compartments for drinks toys and electronic gadgets
  • Surprisingly lightweight
  • Not designed for toddlers or babies who weigh less than 30 pounds
  • Several users complained that the adjustable headrest doesn’t stay where you put it

2. Graco Atlas 65

The Graco Atlas 65 is a versatile car seat that can accommodate a wide range of children of different shapes and sizes.

One feature that you’ll find to be unique is that this seat contains a forward-facing option and a Highback booster mode for growing children.


  • Forward-facing position: 22 to 65 pounds
  • Highback booster mode: 30 to 100 pounds
  • Weight: 16.6 pounds

The forward-facing option that this car seat offers includes a 5-point harness that’s perfect for your small child of 22 to 65 pounds. When your child outgrows the forward-facing option, this car seat changes to a booster mode that is perfect for children of 30 to 100 pounds.

One impressive time-saving feature that you’ll love is the idea that this car seat’s harness and headrest move together. You can find the perfect fit for your child in the shortest time possible using 10 different height positions. You’ll also appreciate the super comfortable reclining positions, and the ample storage for your child’s drinks and toys.

At the time of writing , Other customers of the Graco Atlas 65  have rated this car seat with 4.5-stars on average after 882 unique customer reviews. 76% of reviewers rated this car seat as 5-star, and 13% rated this car seat as 4-stars. Altogether 89% of the total reviewers rated this car seat with either a 4 or 5-star review, which is excellent.

  • Stellar reviews and popularity
  • 10 different height positions
  • Affordable
  • Reclining feature with two settings
  • Ample storage for drinks and objects
  • Not suitable for children or infants who weigh less than 22 pounds
  • A handful of customers mentioned that the installation process was difficult

Car Seat Buyer’s Guide

Congratulations! You’ve just researched a handful of the very best children car seats on the market. You’re a dedicated parent who cares for the comfort and safety of your children, and these car seats can help you in your pursuit of happiness.

Which children’s car seat is the best for your child? There are so many different variables to consider, and often, your gut instinct is the best compass to use. In addition to your gut instinct, however, it’s important to conduct research, and this guide will help you do that!

In this short guide, we’ll spend some time looking at some of the most important considerations for you going forward.

What Are the Most Important Factors When Choosing a Car Seat?

  • How much does your baby weigh? Your child’s weight is arguably the most critical factor.
  • How much do you expect your baby to weigh in 6 months?
  • Does the car seat adjust?
  • Does the car seat in question have stellar reviews?
  • What do the reviewers say about safety?

Never forget that your child looks to you for protection, for comfort, and safety. When you choose the right car seat, you’ll ensure that your child receives the security that they deserve. The right car seat choice can also provide comfort for your child.

What Types of Car Seats Are There?

It can seem a little confusing when you’re choosing the perfect car seat for your child! Always remember not to get overwhelmed. By conducting the research that you are now, you’re putting yourself in a superior position to find the perfect car seat. With that said, let’s take a closer look at the different types of car seats.

There are three major types of car seat categories:

  • Infant car seats. These car seats are usually rear-facing car seats. (See the best options available)
  • Convertible car seats. This type of car seat will change from a rear-facing car seat to a forward-facing car seat as your baby grows.
  • All in one car seats. An all in one car seat is the most versatile type of car seat which will change from rear-facing to forward-facing. The all in one car seat can also eventually change to a booster seat. This type of car seat is designed to change with your children as they grow.

A Few Important Car Seat Tips to Remember for Your Child’s Safety

Remember that you’ve put in the hard work of researching the best car seat for your child! Your child is lucky to have you as their parent or guardian. But your hard work isn’t finished. Please consider these tips for the best results:

  • Always remember to use your car seat consistently! Your children’s car seat doesn’t do any good if you don’t use it each time your child rides in your vehicle.
  • Always follow the instructions that Graco (or any other car seat manufacturer) provides to you.
  • Be sure to maintain your car seat and keep it in good shape. Treat your preferred car seat respectfully because it can potentially save the life of your child one day.
  • If you ever have any questions, please never hesitate to contact Graco or the manufacturer that you choose. It’s always better to be safe than sorry!

Finally, you should also familiarize yourself with The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Their website contains a wealth of resources and information on car seat safety.

Concluding Thoughts

In this guide, we’ve covered a wide array of different car seats from the popular Graco brand. At this point, you should have some idea as to which features, and car seats would be the best for you and your child.

The good news is that no matter which Graco car seat model you choose, the Graco brand is very reliable. Their reviews are excellent on average, and you’ll also find plenty of raving fans who love their car seats.

We congratulate you once again for taking the safety of your child seriously. Please remember to conduct your due diligence when choosing the perfect car seat for your precious child.

We also wish you, your child, and your entire family the absolute best!

Other Car Seat Brands:

About Joanne Stene
Joanne Stene
Joanne is a mother of 2 young girls and a technical writer with over 20 years of professional experience. She originally got interested in the topic of car seats as her two daughters were born and during the course of research into which seats to buy for her family. That interest has turned into a passion of sharing information on the Elite Car Seats website.
Joanne Stene
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *